After hearing from everyone, here is my current thinking starting in April when I DM again.
At this point, I have no reason to assume that I will be working any nights until July, so that means we can have the game on Wednesday night, which appears to be on no ones preferred not list.
We will play in person with masks. This is what the majority prefer in both cases.
We will go back to the 7:30 start time.
Unlike previously, if a players wants to take part virtually, we'll allow that. That said, if the majority of players start deciding to be online, then I would nix the virtual play.
This is of course subject to change based on opinions changing and the reality of cases changing.